A Midsummer Night's Dream as Night Circus

While many of us wait for Julie Taymor's visionary interpretation of A Midsummer Night's Dream to arrive at Brooklyn's Theatre for a New Audience, the other boroughs are providing their own versions of William Shakespeare's fantasy-filled romantic comedy. In Manhattan, the Metropolitan Opera is mounting Benjamin Britten's composition, while the Players Theatre downtown is running the show as the inaugural production of The Theatre Project.  Head across the East River and you'll have the pleasure, as I did Thursday night, to see The Queens Players bring the story to life at the Secret Theatre at 4402 23rd Street in Long Island City.

Although I'd been there before to see a few other shows, I arrived early to make sure I could find the place. Despite its name, the Secret Theatre isn't a problem to locate -- although I did find myself roaming in circles a bit as I searched for the right stage, as if Robin Goodfellow himself was teasing me along.  I shouldn't have worried -- right before the house was opened, a nice crowd of patrons made it hard to miss as they gathered by the entrance to the intimate Poco Space, which was newly built and serves as a marvelous little black box theater.

A Midsummer Night's Dream is one of my favorite plays and one of the Bard's most beloved creations. In addition to the other adaptations mentioned above, any given summer throughout the country will offer countless opportunities to see the now familiar tale unfold, often outdoors. Many of these efforts tend to be uninspired, but the classic continues to endure because it lends itself to so many marvelously creative ways to retell the story.  Now, The Queens Players have given us a fresh take on Shakespeare's whimsical, mind-trippy romp.


Directed by Illana Stein, the timeless events in the enchanted woods near Athens are presented through the black-lit dazzle of a magical wandering night circus. Jonathan Emerson is delightful as the impish Puck, at times setting the stage for what will soon unfold as a sad-eyed mime, at others pulling the strings of all the characters like some godlike ringmaster. When he finally speaks to his fairy kin, taking off his hat to reveal his horns with a mischievous grin, announcing that he is indeed "that merry wanderer of the night," his striped shirt and face paint illuminated with an otherworldy glow, it truly feels as if real magic is about to begin.

The use of black light to distinguish between the world of humans and the realm of the supernatural is a clever choice, used sparingly, just enough to establish the desired effect without becoming an overused gimmick. It actually seemed to become more effective as the plot moved along. (I saw the crew adjusting the overhead lights during intermission, so maybe the subtlety was unintentional, but whatever the case might be, it worked.) 

The circus theme works best with the climactic Mechanicals scene, as they present their play within a play in full clown attire. Even though I've sat through that scene too many times to count over the years, it's a testament to both the cast and Shakespeare's words that this time seemed completely fresh and thrilling. Each one of the working-class thespians is a delight to behold -- Zack Friedman as Snout, Evan Greene as Quince, Ryan Krause as Snug, Marcus Watson as Flute, and the terrific Megan Greener as Starveling. In the standout role of Nick Bottom, Blaine Smith is pitch-perfect, presenting the self-centered performer in all his scene-stealing glory, and providing a believable vocal and physical transformation into an ass with impressively minimal makeup, while also presenting a suprisingly tender side after his metamorphosis is reversed. 


The romantic leads offer some welcome slapstick, often missing in lesser productions, while not skimping on the serious tones that exist in the text beneath all the humor.  Robin Rightmyer as the muscle-bound cad Demetrius and Kathleen Fletcher as the love-starved Helena are both wonderful, bursting with energy and some well played tender moments. At first the chemistry between Lysander, played by the extremely funny Jason Spina, and the beautiful Hermia, brought to life by the spirited Aurora Florence, seems a bit forced, but they quickly won me over as their dynamic personalities take over, conquering both the nightmarish machinations unleashed by Puck's love potion and any initial doubts I may have had.  I was likely a victim of the early propaganda that was spewed against Lysander by Hermia's father Egeus, portrayed competently by Charles Baker, but Spina's non-stop enthusiasm and Florence's emotional verve made me root for them. All four of the lovers come across as endearing and totally entertaining, avoiding the pitfalls that often bewitch the play when those scenes are done by rote instead of the bold fearless abandon that Shakespeare's words necessitate.

The finest moments of the play itself have always been the sparring between Oberon and Titania, loaded with incredible imagery of a world in crisis due to the regal duo's infidelity toward each other. Jeff Dickamore and Kate Siepert are excellent as the magical power couple. As is often done, they also play Theseus and Hippolyta. Titania's fairy army is played by Sheree V. Campbell as Mustardseed, Sabina Friedman-Seitz as Peaseblossom, Jaz Zepatos as Moth, and Megan Greener doubling up as Cobweb, all of whom do a fine job, especially in the dance and song sequences. The hypnotic twirling umbrella is a nice touch, for example.

The director Illana Stein says, "I wanted to take audiences on an invited, exhilarating journey to the unfamiliar, their own private 'Night Circus,' a world controlled by the fairies."

It is indeed exhilarating to return once again to Shakespeare's world of magic and wonder. If you're looking for a few hours of escapist entertainment, filled with laughs, love, and imagination through a story that's enthralled audiences for centuries, accept The Queens Players' invitation and head over to The Secret Theatre to see this fun, fantastical rendition of A Midsummer Night's Dream. The show runs through October 12, 2013.  Get your tickets now.

Comments